Ultimate Guide to Walleye Ice Fishing on Petenwell Lake, Wisconsin's Second Largest: A Complete Resource

  • Posted on

Looking to ice fish Wisconsin's most impressive waters? As the state's second-largest inland lake, Petenwell Lake offers anglers an extraordinary 23,000-acre winter walleye fishing destination. This comprehensive guide covers everything from proven fishing techniques to comfortable lodging at the lakeside Old Abe's Eagle Cabin, ensuring your fishing adventure on this massive body of water is both successful and memorable.

What Makes Petenwell Lake Special?

As Wisconsin's second-largest inland lake, Petenwell Lake (also known as Petenwell Flowage) offers anglers an impressive 23,000 acres of fishing opportunity. Created by damming the Wisconsin River, this magnificent waterbody reaches depths of 44 feet and features unique characteristics that make it a walleye fishing paradise:

  • Deep, submerged river channels that concentrate fish
  • Dramatic underwater structure with steep breaks
  • Stained water that promotes daytime feeding activity
  • Extensive underwater terrain variations that hold fish year-round

Best Techniques for Walleye Ice Fishing Success

1. River Channel Targeting Strategies

The old river channels running through Petenwell Lake are walleye highways. Here's how to fish them effectively:

  • Focus on channel edges where depth changes occur
  • Look for structural elements like points and inside turns
  • Pay special attention to areas where channels intersect with other structure

2. Essential Lure Selection

Your tackle box should include these proven walleye catchers:

  • Rippin' Raps: Bright colors with strong rattles work best in stained water
  • Tingler Spoons: Perfect for triggering strikes from neutral fish
  • Tungsten Bullfly Jigs: Ideal when downsizing is necessary
  • Live Bait Rigs: Use with native baitfish for natural presentation

3. Tip-Up Tactics

Maximize your coverage with strategic tip-up placement:

  • Position units along steep breaks
  • Use larger live bait like blacktail chubs for trophy fish
  • Space tip-ups to cover different depth ranges
  • Check regularly during peak feeding periods

4. Mobile Ice Fishing Approach

Success often requires mobility:

  • Drill multiple holes to test different areas
  • Move away from crowded spots to find unpressured fish
  • Follow daily fish movement patterns
  • Adjust depth and location based on weather conditions

Your Perfect Home Base: Old Abe's Eagle Cabin

Make your Petenwell Lake ice-fishing adventure complete with a stay at Old Abe's Eagle Cabin. This ideal angler's retreat offers:

Amenities That Matter to Anglers

  • Prime Location: Minutes from prime fishing spots and deeded access to Petenwell Lake
  • Gear Storage: Secure space for all your equipment
  • Comfortable Interior: Warm up after a day on the ice at the wood-burning fireplace
  • Modern Conveniences: All the comforts of home and a full basement game room
  • Stunning Views: Appreciate Wisconsin's winter beauty

Why Choose Old Abe's Eagle Cabin?

  • Perfect blend of rustic charm and modern comfort
  • Ideal for fishing groups
  • Close proximity to multiple lake access points
  • Peaceful setting for planning your next day's strategy

Planning Your Trip

Best Times to Visit

  • Early ice (December): First ice often provides excellent action
  • Mid-winter (January-February): Stable patterns develop
  • Late ice (March): Pre-spawn feeding increases activity

Essential Gear Checklist

  • Quality ice auger
  • Reliable electronics
  • Selection of jigging rods and tip-ups
  • Variety of lures and live bait options
  • Proper ice safety equipment
  • Warm, layered clothing

Safety First

  • Always check ice conditions before venturing out
  • Bring ice picks and flotation devices
  • Fish with a partner when possible
  • Tell someone your planned location and return time

Ready to Experience World-Class Ice Fishing?

Petenwell Lake offers some of Wisconsin's finest walleye ice fishing opportunities, and Old Abe's Eagle Cabin provides the perfect home base for your adventure. Book your stay today and experience the perfect combination of outstanding fishing and comfortable accommodations.  Limited availability during prime ice fishing season!

Keywords: Petenwell Lake ice fishing, Wisconsin walleye fishing, ice fishing guides, fishing cabin rental, winter fishing Wisconsin, Old Abe's Eagle Cabin, fishing accommodation Wisconsin